Auditor Negligence in Singapore: Deloitte v Hin Leong and Claims for Trading Losses

Home / Information / Auditor Negligence in Singapore: Deloitte v Hin Leong and Claims for Trading Losses
auditor-negligence-singapore
Auditor Negligence in Singapore: Deloitte v Hin Leong and Claims for Trading Losses
Introduction

When a company collapses after years of undetected fraud, its liquidators often consider a claim for auditor negligence. In Deloitte & Touche LLP v Hin Leong Trading (Pte) Ltd (in compulsory liquidation) (“Hin Leong”), the Court of Appeal considered whether a company can recover from its auditor the losses it made by continuing to trade while the fraud went undetected. It held that those losses were too remote. Because the framing of a claim can decide whether parts of it survive a strike-out application, advice should be taken before pleadings are filed.

What Was the Case About?

Hin Leong Trading (Pte) Ltd (“HLT”) was formerly one of Asia’s largest oil traders. In April 2020, it came to light that HLT was deeply insolvent, amid widespread allegations of fraud by its controllers, and it entered insolvent liquidation. Deloitte & Touche LLP (“Deloitte”) had been HLT’s external auditor and had issued unqualified audit opinions for each financial year from 2014 to 2019.

HLT, acting by its liquidators, sued Deloitte for professional negligence. It alleged that Deloitte had failed to detect and report fraud and irregularities, including fictitious profits and overstated receivables and inventory. The largest head of loss, quantified at US$2.6 billion, was the loss HLT made from trading between November 2015 and mid-April 2020 (the “Trading Losses”). HLT’s case was that, but for Deloitte’s negligence, it would have been put into liquidation earlier and would not have incurred them.

Deloitte applied to strike out parts of the claim. On the appeal, the facts pleaded by HLT were assumed to be true, so the Court of Appeal did not decide whether Deloitte had in fact been negligent.

What Must a Claimant Prove in Negligence?

The Court of Appeal set out the requirements of a claim in negligence. The claimant must show that:

  • It suffered injury actionable in negligence;
  • The defendant owed it a duty of care;
  • The defendant breached that duty; and
  • The breach was a factual cause of the injury.

The injury must also not be too remote, meaning that it falls within the appropriate scope of the defendant’s legal responsibility, and the defendant must have no defence.

The court warned against conflating these elements. A duty of care is a broad duty to take reasonable care, not a duty to do or not do particular things. What reasonable care required is a question of breach, and therefore of fact. The extent of liability is a question of remoteness, not of the scope of the duty of care.

Why Were the Trading Losses Not Recoverable?

Earlier cases had generally held that auditors are not liable for losses a company incurs by continuing to trade, but the reasons given were inconsistent. Some treated the losses as not legally caused by the auditor’s negligence, as a matter of “common sense”. Others relied on the “scope of duty” principle in South Australia Asset Management Corp v York Montague Ltd (“SAAMCo”).

The Court of Appeal found the SAAMCo approach unsatisfactory. A duty of care is a broad duty to take reasonable care, not a duty to do or not do particular things. The court held instead that the SAAMCo principle is better explained by, and subsumed within, the ordinary rule of remoteness in contract in Hadley v Baxendale.

That rule asks what loss the defendant can be taken to have assumed responsibility for, based on what was within its contemplation when the contract was made. Because Deloitte owed concurrent duties in contract and tort, the contractual rule applied.

Applying that rule, the court held that the Trading Losses were too remote for four reasons:

  • Deloitte had no involvement in HLT’s trading. It could not have contemplated liability for losses from that trading. The court found it inconceivable that an auditor performing a statutory audit had signed up to “insure HLT’s trading fortunes”.
  • The statutory framework required a higher degree of knowledge. Liability for fraudulent or wrongful trading depends on actual knowledge of the fraud, or that debts were being incurred with no reasonable prospect of repayment. Deloitte would not have contemplated liability for continued trading on a lower degree of knowledge.
  • Obtaining financing did not itself cause loss. Even if the misstated accounts helped HLT to obtain financing, obtaining financing did not itself cause loss, and how HLT used that financing was outside Deloitte’s knowledge.
  • HLT’s trading was not inherently likely to make losses. HLT could have traded at a profit, and did so in one year, so its trading was not so inherently likely to make losses that losses fell within Deloitte’s contemplation.

The court ordered the parts of HLT’s claim relating to the Trading Losses to be struck out. It declined to decide whether Deloitte owed a duty to have regard to the interests of HLT’s creditors, holding that the question was academic and, in any event, not suitable for summary determination.


Why Does It Matter Whether the Claim Is in Contract or Tort?

The two remoteness tests differ. In tort, under The Wagon Mound, loss is too remote if it was not of a reasonably foreseeable type at the time of the breach.

In contract, under Hadley v Baxendale, the defendant is liable only for loss within its contemplation at the time of contracting. The contractual test is narrower, because the parties had the opportunity to allocate the risk of loss in their contract.

Where an adviser is engaged under a contract, as an auditor is, the narrower contractual test will generally govern the losses that can be recovered.


What Does the Decision Mean for Professional Negligence Claims?

The decision does not say whether Deloitte was negligent, because that question was not before the court. It decides the framework for the losses that can be recovered if negligence is proved. Two points follow:

  • Identify the losses within the adviser’s assumed responsibility. A claim must identify losses that the adviser can be taken to have assumed responsibility for when it was engaged, and losses from a company’s continued trading will generally fall outside what a statutory auditor assumes.
  • Plead the duty and breach correctly. The duty of care should be pleaded as a duty to take reasonable care, while specific steps the adviser should have taken, such as reporting to third parties, go to breach and are questions of fact.

Taking Advice Early

Claims against auditors and other professional advisers often arise in insolvency, when liquidators review the company’s affairs and the work of those who advised it. Hin Leong shows that the duty, the breach and the losses claimed must each be analysed correctly before pleadings are filed.

A liquidator, creditor or director considering such a claim, and a professional firm facing one, should take advice early from a civil litigation lawyer in Singapore.

Jerrie Tan LLC is a law firm in Singapore. It acts in commercial and civil litigation and in personal and corporate insolvency matters.

This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. It does not create a solicitor-client relationship. Outcomes depend on the specific facts of each matter. Please seek advice on your own circumstances.

This article was written by Jerrie Tan, Founding Director, and Lim Yuhang, of Jerrie Tan LLC.

Jerrie Tan

Jerrie Tan

Author & Contributor

Jerrie Tan (陈秋琳) is a dispute lawyer whose practice spans commercial litigation and serious criminal defence. She has acted in complex commercial disputes and high-stakes criminal matters, even those involving the death penalty. Jerrie brings a strategic approach to cases where financial, regulatory, and reputational risks often intersect.

View All Resources by Jerrie Tan