Wrongful Dismissal in Singapore After JJF v JJG

Home / Information / Wrongful Dismissal in Singapore After JJF v JJG
wrongful-dismissal-lawyer
Wrongful Dismissal in Singapore After JJF v JJG
Introduction

Compliance with the employment contract is not the end of the matter. In JJF v JJG [2026] SGECT 9 (“JJF”), the Employment Claims Tribunals (“ECT”) held that an employee dismissed under an express termination clause, with salary in lieu and no reason given, had nonetheless been dismissed “without just cause or excuse” under s 14(2) of the Employment Act 1968 (“EA”). He succeeded even though the ECT rejected his allegation of discrimination. The employer has obtained leave to appeal.

The Statutory Claim

Section 14(2) gives a relevant employee who considers that he or she was dismissed without just cause or excuse a claim for reinstatement or compensation. The Employment Claims Act 2016 (“ECA”) calls this a “wrongful dismissal dispute”, and it is often described as unfair dismissal. It is distinct from the common law action for breach of the employment contract.

“Dismiss” includes termination with or without notice and for cause or otherwise, so notice or salary in lieu may satisfy the contract without answering the statutory claim. A managerial or executive employee dismissed with notice or salary in lieu must have served at least six months; other employees need no minimum service.

What JJF Decides

The employer relied on the Tripartite Guidelines on Wrongful Dismissal (“Guidelines”). Paragraph 9 states that an employee dismissed with notice, where no reason is given, must substantiate a wrongful reason, such as discrimination. The ECT must have regard to the Guidelines, but they do not have the force of legislation, and where they cannot be reconciled with s 14(2), the statute prevails. The ECT held that:

  • The relevant parts of the Guidelines are not consistent with the plain wording of s 14(2). Paragraph 7 presumes that a dismissal with notice is not wrongful, and para 9 requires the employee to substantiate a wrongful reason, but notice cannot by itself constitute just cause or excuse, and Parliament enacted no such presumption;
  • Liability turns on whether the dismissal lacked justification, not on whether the employee can prove a wrongful reason. The employer’s basis for dismissal must have existed, operated on the decision and been sufficient, in the circumstances, to justify it; and
  • The question of justification may arise even where the employer had, and validly exercised, a contractual power to end the employment.

An employer need not state its reason when it dismisses, but a cause that did not exist at the time cannot be created afterwards. Under s 27(2) of the ECA, the employer bears the burden of proof where the employee was dismissed without notice under s 14(1) of the EA, or was given notice on the ground of poor performance or misconduct. An immediate termination with salary in lieu falls outside both, so the burden stays with the employee, who may discharge it with circumstantial evidence.

The Facts

The employee was a Senior Construction Manager whom the employer had confirmed after probation, paid a bonus and given a raise. In June 2025 he was diagnosed with major depression and anxiety, and from 1 July he worked regular hours in the employer’s tender team. The day after the tender was submitted, the employer ended his employment under the termination clause, paying one week’s salary in lieu and his full August salary. It gave no reason.

Why the Dismissal Was Without Just Cause or Excuse

The ECT rejected the allegation of discrimination, because the employer had sought medical information, honoured his medical leave and moved him to regular hours.

The employee’s record nevertheless called for an answer as to whether he was subject to unfair dismissal. The employer’s defence treated compliance with the termination clause in the employment contract, and the Guidelines, as answering the claim unless the employee proved discrimination. That reliance on the Guidelines was misplaced for the reasons above, and the employer was required to have a reason that was substantiated to justify dismissal.

The Tribunal looked at the evidence, which did not show that there was a reason sufficient to justify dismissal of the employee:

  • The site-project incident: The employee had left concrete works without ensuring that a supply shortage was addressed. This was proved and probably operated on the decision to dismiss, but it was a confined shortfall that was insufficient to justify dismissal;
  • Wider concerns about performance and suitability: Some concern probably existed and operated on the decision to dismiss, but its extent was uncertain, such that dismissal was not justified;
  • The tender work: The criticisms of the employee’s plans, schedule and conduct could not be established to the seriousness asserted, because the managers who assessed that employee’s work were not called. The employer’s own position also left it uncertain whether they had operated on the decision at all; and
  • Business and operational considerations: The evidence identified no reorganisation, redundancy or other event that could be tested.

What remained was a confined shortfall and some concerns of uncertain extent. Against a record of confirmation, a bonus, a raise and continued responsible work, that was not weighty enough to justify dismissal.

Remedies

Compensation comprises loss of income, capped at three months of gross pay, and compensation for harm, which starts from a base of up to two months’ pay adjusted by up to 50%.

The ECT took the maximum base ($18,300), deducted 0.75 month for the site-project shortfall and awarded $11,437.50. It made no award for loss of income, because the employee did not establish how long his employment would probably have continued. It could not compel the apology he sought.

What the Decision Means

A valid contractual termination does not answer a claim under s 14(2) EA. If a claim is brought, the employer must identify the actual basis of its decision and be ready to prove, with contemporaneous records and the evidence of those who made the decision, that a reason existed, operated on the decision to dismiss, and justified dismissal.

JJF is a first-instance decision, and the employer has obtained leave to appeal, which lies only on a question of law or jurisdiction. Several related questions also remain unresolved, so the legal position may change.

Taking Advice Early

An employer should take advice before a termination, while the actual ground and the records that support it can still be settled. An employee should take advice early too, because the time limits are short and the ECT ordinarily excludes legal representation.

An employment lawyer in Singapore can advise on the contractual and statutory claims and the forum for each.

Jerrie Tan LLC is a law firm in Singapore. It acts for employers and senior employees in employment disputes, including dismissals connected with misconduct, investigations or regulatory issues.

This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. It does not create a solicitor-client relationship. Outcomes depend on the specific facts of each matter. Please seek advice on your own circumstances.

This article was written by Jerrie Tan, Founding Director, and Lim Yuhang, of Jerrie Tan LLC.

Jerrie Tan

Jerrie Tan

Author & Contributor

Jerrie Tan (陈秋琳) is a dispute lawyer whose practice spans commercial litigation and serious criminal defence. She has acted in complex commercial disputes and high-stakes criminal matters, even those involving the death penalty. Jerrie brings a strategic approach to cases where financial, regulatory, and reputational risks often intersect.

View All Resources by Jerrie Tan