Non-Compete Clauses in Singapore: When Are Restrictive Covenants Enforceable?
Introduction
Many employment contracts contain a non-compete, non-solicitation or non-dealing clause. In Singapore law, these are restraint of trade clauses, and they are prima facie void and unenforceable unless the employer can justify them. Whether a clause can be justified turns on its wording and on the circumstances when it was agreed, so an employer drafting a non-compete clause, and an employee asked to sign one, should take legal advice early.
What Is the Legal Test?
The starting point is the public policy against unreasonable restrictions on freedom of trade, as reflected in Man Financial (S) Pte Ltd v Wong Bark Chuan David (“Man Financial”) and Shopee Singapore Pte Ltd v Lim Teck Yong (“Shopee”). Against that starting point is the freedom of parties to contract. As a balance between the two competing interests, a restrictive covenant is enforceable only if all three of the following requirements are met:
- It protects a legitimate proprietary interest of the employer;
- It is reasonable in the interests of the parties; and
- It is reasonable in the public interest.
Reasonableness is assessed at the time the covenant was entered into, having regard to the circumstances the parties reasonably contemplated then: HT SRL v Wee Shuo Woon (“HT SRL”).
What Interests Can an Employer Protect?
The courts have recognised three legitimate proprietary interests, although the categories are not closed.
- Trade secrets and confidential information. The employer must specifically identify the information, as a general assertion will not do, and must show on the evidence that the employee had acquired it.
- Trade connection. The employer must show that the employee had personal knowledge of, and influence over, its customers, such that the employee could take advantage of that connection.
- A stable, trained workforce. This interest usually supports a clause against soliciting the employer’s staff, and does not depend on any confidential information.
What If Another Clause Already Protects That Interest?
In Singapore, where an interest is already protected by another clause, such as a confidentiality clause, the employer must show that the restraint protects a legitimate interest over and above it. Otherwise, the restraint merely stifles competition.
In Shopee, the employer’s confidential information was already protected by a separate confidentiality agreement, and the non-compete did not protect anything beyond it. In HT SRL, confidential information and customer connections were covered by other clauses, and the High Court doubted that the restraint protected any further interest.
The High Court in Lek Gwee Noi v Humming Flowers & Gifts Pte Ltd noted English decisions that allow a non-compete alongside a confidentiality clause, because confidentiality obligations are hard to police. The Man Financial position nonetheless remains the law in Singapore.
When Is a Restraint Reasonable?
As between the parties, the courts consider whether the agreement was made in good faith and free of vitiating factors such as duress, undue influence or unconscionability, and whether the employer gave something in return for the restraint.
The scope of the restraint is often decisive. In HT SRL, a restriction extending to businesses with no close connection to the employer, with no geographical or time limit, was excessive. In Shopee, a restraint covering every market in which the employer operated, including markets the employee had no responsibility for, was excessive.
The public interest is a separate question, because a restraint may be reasonable between the parties but contrary to the public interest. In Thomas Cowan & Co Ltd v Orme, a restraint was unenforceable because it would have given the plaintiffs a virtual monopoly over fumigation services in Singapore.
Can an Unreasonable Clause Be Cut Down?
An unreasonable clause can be cut down only by “blue pencil” severance. The court may strike out offending words if it can do so without altering the meaning of what remains or rendering it senseless. The remaining terms must still be supported by consideration, and severance must not change the fundamental character of the contract.
Singapore has not accepted notional severance, under which a court would read an unreasonable restraint down to what would have been reasonable. In Smile Inc Dental Surgeons Pte Ltd v Lui Andrew Stewart, the Court of Appeal explained that this would amount to rewriting the covenant, create uncertainty, and encourage employers to impose unreasonable restraints in the knowledge that the court would enforce them to the extent of what was reasonable.
How Does Singapore Compare with the UK, Hong Kong and Australia?
The basic test is the same in all four jurisdictions: a restraint is unenforceable unless it protects a legitimate interest and is reasonable, judged at the time of contracting. The differences lie in how the courts construe the clause, and whether a non-compete can sit alongside a confidentiality clause.
| Issue | Singapore | United Kingdom | Hong Kong | Australia |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non-compete alongside a confidentiality clause | Must protect an interest over and above other clauses (Man Financial). | May be justified because confidentiality is hard to police (Harcus Sinclair). | Follows the UK position (BFAM Partners). | Trade connection and confidential information are protectable interests. |
| Construction | Considered before reasonableness. | Where a realistic lawful reading exists, it is preferred (Egon Zehnder). | Follows the UK approach. | Construed to give a commercial result, without rewriting the clause (Findex). |
| Severance | “Blue pencil” only; no notional severance. | “Blue pencil” test (Tillman). | Follows the UK approach. | Words may be removed, not rewritten. |
For employers with staff in more than one of these jurisdictions, the practical point is that a non-compete drafted to sit alongside a confidentiality clause may be upheld in the United Kingdom or Hong Kong but not in Singapore, unless it protects an interest that the other clauses do not.
Taking Advice Early
Whether a restraint is enforceable depends on the interest it protects, its scope and the circumstances when it was agreed. Employers should take legal advice when drafting a restraint, tie it to a specific interest, limit it in activity, area and duration, and check whether existing confidentiality and non-solicitation clauses already cover that interest.
Employees should review their restraints before resigning or accepting a role with a competitor. If you are drafting, relying on or facing a restrictive covenant, speak to an employment lawyer in Singapore early.
Jerrie Tan LLC is a law firm in Singapore. It acts for employers and senior employees in employment disputes, including disputes over restrictive covenants.
This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. It does not create a solicitor-client relationship. Outcomes depend on the specific facts of each matter. Please seek advice on your own circumstances.
This article was written by Jerrie Tan, Founding Director, and Lim Yuhang, of Jerrie Tan LLC.
